Ebook Reflections on Judging

Ebook Reflections on Judging

Therefore, you can take Reflections On Judging as one of your reading materials today. Even you still have the other publication; you can develop your determination to truly get this significant book. It will certainly always provide benefits from some sides. Reading this kind of book also will certainly lead you to have even more experiences that others have not.

Reflections on Judging

Ebook Reflections on Judging

Reflections On Judging. Eventually, you will certainly discover a brand-new journey as well as expertise by investing more money. Yet when? Do you believe that you require to obtain those all demands when having significantly money? Why do not you aim to obtain something simple in the beginning? That's something that will lead you to understand even more about the world, adventure, some areas, past history, amusement, and also a lot more? It is your personal time to continue reviewing behavior. One of the publications you can take pleasure in now is Reflections On Judging here.

We understand that everyone will certainly require different publication to read. The needs will certainly depend upon just how they collaborate with. When they need the resources from the various other country, we will certainly not let them really feel so difficult. We offer guides from abroad quickly based on the soft documents supplied in web link checklists. All publications that we supply are in simple methods to link and also get, as the Reflections On Judging in soft file in this web site.

Nonetheless, the existence of this book really heals that you must alter that mind. Not all best books make use of the difficult impression to take. Therefore, you must be so better to get over the existence of the book to get all finest. This term connects to the content of this publication. Even it features the most preferred subject to discuss; the visibility of language and also words that are blended with the history of the author will really come appropriately

Collect the book Reflections On Judging start from now. But the new means is by gathering the soft data of guide Reflections On Judging Taking the soft file can be saved or saved in computer or in your laptop computer. So, it can be more than a book Reflections On Judging that you have. The simplest way to disclose is that you could additionally conserve the soft file of Reflections On Judging in your appropriate as well as offered gadget. This condition will suppose you frequently read Reflections On Judging in the spare times greater than chatting or gossiping. It will not make you have bad habit, yet it will lead you to have better practice to read book Reflections On Judging.

Review

Reflections on Judging…is about what judges should do when confronted with complexity. Like the rest of us, judges face an increasingly bewildering world, marked by daily advances in such areas as social media, the sciences and globalization. Unlike the rest of us, judges must make decisions that enforce their understanding―or misunderstanding―of that complexity onto millions… [Posner’s] willingness to speak to his readers―judges or otherwise―as a jurist with three decades of experience is a strength of this book… Reflections on Judging is spangled with legal cases in which Posner, faced with disorder, triumphantly cuts through the noise… In Richard A. Posner, our generation has its Learned Hand, its Henry Friendly. In complex times, we can take comfort in the simple fact of his existence. (Kenji Yoshino New York Times Book Review 2013-11-10)Posner is a precise, erudite writer with a strong point of view enriched by specific examples accumulated over the course of three decades of professional experience and observation… Posner's insights will resonate with jurists and those who practice before them. His book is highly recommended for those in the legal profession and other court watchers. (Joan Pedzich Library Journal (starred review) 2013-09-01)A deep and thought-provoking collection of insightful analyses of various aspects of being a judge, told from an insider's perspective, but with appropriate and equally thoughtful caveats about the advantages and disadvantages of an insider's account. (Frederick Schauer, University of Virginia School of Law)

Read more

About the Author

Richard A. Posner is Circuit Judge, the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, and a senior lecturer at the University of Chicago Law School.

Read more

Product details

Hardcover: 400 pages

Publisher: Harvard University Press; First Edition edition (October 7, 2013)

Language: English

ISBN-10: 9780674725089

ISBN-13: 978-0674725089

ASIN: 0674725085

Product Dimensions:

6 x 1.3 x 9.3 inches

Shipping Weight: 1.8 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)

Average Customer Review:

4.4 out of 5 stars

13 customer reviews

Amazon Best Sellers Rank:

#535,407 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)

Judge Posner's "Reflections" is a readable and witty overview of the challenges facing the judiciary and legal profession in a time of increasingly complex cases.Judge Posner invites lawyers and judges to tackle the increased complexity of the law in at least three ways. First, he urges lawyers and judges to use pictures and simplify their briefs and opinions. For example, he writes that "seeing a case makes it come alive to judges," yet "[l]awyers' lack of a visual sense . . . is a striking professional deformity. I do not understand it. Information can often be presented more efficiently in pictorial than verbal form." He also tells lawyers and judges to use "coloring book" facts, such as stories or other background material (even if outside the record) to help the reader understand "the technological or commercial setting of a case."Second, despite his reputation as a legal theorist, Judge Posner has practical tips to improve jury trials based on his experiences from serving as a trial judge. Among other things, he advocates time limits on trials and recommends that judges use more frequently their power to appoint neutral experts.Third, Judge Posner presents his "Posner model" of avoiding excessive reliance on junior lawyers or clerks preparing briefs and opinions. He correctly observes that the growth of associates in law firms and law clerks in the federal courts has contributed to the unnecessary lengthening of briefs and opinions. He goes as far as to present an opinion from a federal appeals court that takes up several pages of text and compares his version, which takes a little more than a page. The difference is striking.In short, Judge Posner's "Reflections" should help lawyers and judges to argue and rule more effectively and with more style and more professional satisfaction. Hopefully, in the process, this will improve the public's confidence in the judicial system.

It is easy to see from this book why Judge Posner has become the most frequently cited legal commentator. His range of interests is immense, ranging from law and economics, to national security issues, to the 2000 election, and various jurisprudential topics. Recently, he has focused on his colleagues, federal judges, in several books. This book continues that interest. It is diverse in topics and approaches; but always informative and stimulating.First, to illustrate how one can be selected for the federal judiciary, he devotes the introductory chapter to a brief autobiography. He is particularly interested in suggesting issues that new judges should consider as they ascend the bench. He also introduces one of his major concerns: increasing technical "complexity" that faces judges as they adjudicate challenging cases.To fill in background, Posner next discusses the evolution of the federal judiciary. He raises here several of his fundamental concerns: excessive growth of staff; should law clerks on the appellate level be assigned initial drafting responsibility for opinions (a vehement no!); and the adoption of basic managerial tools to structure judicial caseloads.A third chapter is devoted to his key concern of "complexity." I found this very long chapter not to be particularly effective. He does a better and shorter job on this in his Introduction to the book. One important point that does emerge is that courts may generate their own complexity by deciding cases in a "formalistic" way rather than employing a realistic approach. This reflects Posner's recent shift toward pragmatism in his writings. He develops this theme in depth in his chapter four. Basically instead of conventional legal analysis, Posner wants judges to employ more practical sense and concern about the consequences of their decisions. I think this is one of his most crucial points and this chapter bears careful reading.Posner argues that appellate records are often insufficient. Surprisingly, to me at least, he advocates that appellate judges freely utilize Google research to fill out inadequate factual records. More use should be made of maps and pictures in opinions to help clarify decisions. Counsel who argue appellate cases should find this chapter of particular interest.A most interesting chapter is on "coping strategies." These are techniques appellate judges can use to avoid resolving complexities they face in cases. Judicial self-restraint comes in for a challenging working over by Posner. A particularly rich chapter discusses the very concept of interpretation. His target here is (not for the first time) Justice Scalia's originalism, as discussed in depth in his book (co-authored with Brian Gardner) "Reading Law." By the time his extensive analysis is concluded, its brutal efficiency leaves little of the Scalia approach still standing. This is as fine an example of masterful legal analysis as I have seen. Given all the fussing over how to interpret statutes and the Constitution, this chapter makes a significant contribution to bringing some clarity to this debate.Several more chapters are directed at the appellate process. Tips on opinion writing and appellate advocacy comprise chapter 8. In the next chapter, Posner recounts why he recommends that appellate judges without trial experience spend some time presiding (as they may) over district court trials. Chapter 10 discusses additional recommendations to improve the appellate process. A conclusion raps it all up.So, Posner covers a large amount of ground in 370 pages. This is one of those books where reading the footnotes (which are actually footnotes) is essential. Sometimes the judge does go on a bit too long in making a point (witness the complexity chapter); but if this is "fat" I am all for it. One of the most stimulating books one can read on the federal appellate judiciary, which what with the recent filibuster modifications, is as always heating up as an issue.

Reflections on Judging PDF
Reflections on Judging EPub
Reflections on Judging Doc
Reflections on Judging iBooks
Reflections on Judging rtf
Reflections on Judging Mobipocket
Reflections on Judging Kindle

Reflections on Judging PDF

Reflections on Judging PDF

Reflections on Judging PDF

Reflections on Judging PDF